Soybean Pests

Thistle Caterpillar

Overview

The thistle caterpillar, Vanessa cardui, is the larva of the adult painted lady butterfly. It takes its name from the Canada thistle, which is a preferred host. It is considered a sporadic pest of soybean. Larvae have a wide host range that includes over 300 plant species.

This pest does not overwinter in northern growing areas but migrates up from southern states and Mexico each spring. Eggs are laid singly on the upper side of leaves of host plants, including Canada thistle, sunflower, and soybean. Caterpillars hatch and form webs by tying leaves together with silk, which creates a protected area for them to feed in. Caterpillars feed on leaves causing defoliation in the upper canopy of the soybean plant. After two to six weeks, they form a chrysalis, which hangs from the host plant. After seven to 10 days, the butterfly emerges. There are two generations per year in the Midwest but there may only be one in more northern production areas.

Scouting

Adults (Figure 1)

  • Upper side of front wings are red–orange and brown, with black and white spots.
  • Hindwings are red–orange and brown, with four black “eye spots” along the edge.

Figure 1. Adult painted lady butterfly.

Eggs

  • Eggs are light green and barrel–shaped.

Caterpillar/larva (Figure 2)

  • The brown to black body is one and one-fourth inches long and has yellow striping on both sides.
  • Branched, spiny hairs covering the body give the caterpillar a prickly appearance.

Caterpillars form a webbing in the leaves where they feed.

Figure 2. Painted lady (thistle) caterpillar. Photo: University of Nebraska – Lincoln, CropWatch

 

Thistle caterpillars tend to aggregate toward the field edges, especially if there is Canada thistle present along the edges.

To estimate percent defoliation, examine a minimum of 10 plants:

  1. From each plant, select a leaf from the top, middle and bottom third of the plant.
  2. Use Figure 3 to estimate percent defoliation for each leaf and calculate the average percent defoliation across the three leaves from each plant and then across the multiple plants.
  3. This average percent defoliation for the field’s canopy can be compared to treatment thresholds.

Figure 3. Levels of soybean defoliation. Injury is often overestimated. CropWatch – University of Nebraska – Lincoln

Treatment Thresholds for Caterpillars in Soybeans
In vegetative (pre-flowering) stages, consider treatment if the insects are present and feeding, and defoliation will exceed 30%. In pod-forming or pod-filling stages, consider treatment if the insects are present and defoliation will exceed 20%. This normally requires about 8 to 10 caterpillars per foot of row. If plants are still small, then best judgement may have to be made. One reference suggests a treatment guideline of 3 larvae per row foot in young soybeans, another when damage is severe and plants are being killed.

Keep in mind, other foliar feeding insects including soybean looper, green cloverworm and grasshoppers may be feeding at the same time and defoliation damage is cumulative among the pests present.

Insecticide treatments
Several foliar insecticides labelled on soybeans have activity against these and other caterpillars. Consult your state Extension office for recommended products and rates. Always read and follow label directions for use.

Resources

Thistle Caterpillar,
Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Integrated Crop Management

Thistle Caterpillar in Soybean
University of Nebraska – Lincoln, CropWatch, 2019

Thistle Caterpillar on Soybean
University of Minnesota Extension


Information on this pest is provided by Douglas J. Jardine, Professor Emeritus, Kansas State University 5/2020