New Study Confirms that IPM is a Better Pest Management Investment for Soybean Aphid than Seed Treatment
by Christian Krupke, Soybean Entomologist, Purdue University
We recently compared neonicotinoid seed treatment for managing soybean aphid to an integrated pest
management (IPM) approach that included monitoring soybean aphids and
treating with foliar-applied insecticide only when the economic
threshold was reached.
The two-year study, conducted on a large geographic area, confirmed earlier studies that even during periods of aphid infestation, neonicotinoid seed treatment produced the same yields as using no insecticide at all.
The grower-funded study was conducted in Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, North Dakota, South Dakota, Minnesota, and Wisconsin with checkoff funds provided by the North Central Soybean Research Program. The results were recently reported in the April 2017 issue of Pest Management Science.
We found that by the V2 stage, the amount of thiamethoxam, the neonicotinoid insecticide applied as a coating to soybean seeds, in plant tissue was statistically similar to plants grown from untreated seeds. As a result, when soybean aphid populations reached threshold levels, from late July to August, the insecticide levels in tissues of neonicotinoid-treated soybean foliage were similar to plants grown from seeds without the insecticide. Therefore, thiamethoxam concentrations in foliage are unlikely to effectively manage soybean aphids for most of the pests’ activity period across the region.
Both the IPM treatment and thiamethoxam-treated seed resulted in significant reductions in cumulative aphid days when soybean aphid populations reached threshold levels. But while the IPM treatment resulted in significant yield increases, the neonicotinoid treatment produced the same yields as using no insecticide at all.
The relevance of this information for soybean producers is that an IPM approach, combining scouting and foliar-applied insecticide where
necessary, remains a better pest management investment for soybean aphid in the North Central region, both in terms of protecting the yield potential of the crop, and in terms of break-even probability for producers. This is important because millions of dollars are spent in the region
each year for a pest management product (insecticidal seed treatment)
that doesn’t deliver good value.For more information
The Effectiveness of Neonicotinoid Seed Treatments in Soybean
, a free resource guide to help growers assess if and when to use neonicotinoid seed treatments. Authored by 17 Midwestern entomologists and available through Purdue University Extension.Soybean Aphid Management Using Neonicotinoid-Treated Seed
, webinar by Christian Krupke, hosted by the Plant Management Network.Assessing the value and pest management window provided by neonicotinoid seed treatments for management of soybean aphid in the Upper Midwestern United States -
Pest Management Science, 2017Multi-state research reveals Integrated Pest Management (IPM) best option for treatment of soybean aphids
- Press Release from Purdue University
A recently published study conducted at Purdue University examining neonicotinoid seed treatments of corn had a similar result. See: Translocation of the neonicotinoid seed treatment clothianidin in maize,